Monday, May 24, 2010

TWIOT, SPECIAL MONDAY EDITION: LOST - The End

The Reason for the Series


LOST's series finale, as expected, was a polarizing show that divided fans into a few major sects. It's not surprising, as the show itself has conjured rifts amongst the fanbase in its six years of air-time. In the end, I was in the camp of people who were more than satisfied with what the two-and-a-half hour episode presented to me. I found closure that I was afraid I wasn't going to get. I got emotion, power, beauty, meaning and a message, even if they didn't provide answers to questions that they posed during the run of the show. I can understand why people might have been angry at that lack of answers. I will never begrudge someone the way they feel, unless that feeling is based in ignorance (LOOKING AT YOU, LOST BASHERS WHO'VE NEVER WATCHED SO MUCH AS A MINUTE OF THE SHOW). However, I feel like the lack of answers is par for the course for the show, and while some may see it as a cop out, I thought it was fitting to give the fans something to chew on, something to wonder about, a way to enjoy the show even now that it's off the air.

After the jump...I think part of the reason why LOST has been such an intelligent show isn't because of the introduction of electromagnetic theories or the positing of time travel or the multiple complex interactions or anything that was explicitly written in the canon. To me, the show was intelligent because it inspired intelligent conversation and debate. No other show that I can think of has made its fanbase come up with the massive amounts of theories and discussion about said theories. The show's mythology has always been this burgeoning behemoth that was greater than anything Carlton Cuse, Damon Lindelof or any of the writers could have dreamed of. The only thing that separates LOST's mythos from the pages and pages of non-canonical Expanded Universe material in the Star Wars fandom is that the only published LOST extra stuff is on theory websites and blogs.

That's why I feel like the lack of answers given was not only appropriate but needed. There was no reason for the creators and writers of the show to give every bit of minutia, and I bet that it wouldn't have been satisfactory for some vocal contingient of those clamoring for answers anyway. Be that as it may, I thought it as a propos that we didn't get the writers dogma. We got an opportunity to continue debating, discussing, arguing and wondering about what the Island's truths really are. Some see it as a curse, I see it as a gift. Some of the best stories leave you wanting more. Some leave you wanting too much, which is the vibe I got from Sopranos fans after their series finale ended with the family eating onion rings.

With LOST, I feel like we got enough closure, a magnificent ending that felt befitting of the show. I loved the message, that life wasn't necessarily about reaching an end but about the people you spend the journey with. It's not anything new, but the way it was presented was where the power came from. The reunions of Sawyer and Juliet, Shannon and Sayid, Charlie and Claire. The real John Locke appearing again and reassuring everyone that everything was going to end up alright. Jack's final meeting with his father. Everything was executed so well, and the point was reinforced over and over again with elegance and force. The resolution was succinct and effective. We got an answer to what the "flash-sideways" universe was, and it made sense, their mission in that universe made sense. We didn't need to see what the escapees from the Island did in the rest of their lives. We only needed to know that they moved on with their lives. We didn't need a dissertation on how Hurley and Ben ran the Island after everyone left. We only needed to know that they were successful through their exchange before Hurley entered the church for the final time. We didn't need to know how Desmond made it back to Penny and little Charlie. We only needed to trust that he did, because Hurley changed the rules and reigned over the Island with a much better attitude and policy than Jacob ever could.

Besides, the show was never about them anyway. It was about Jack Shephard. Like Jimmy Kimmel postulated last night, the show was about the life and times of Jack, and it was mainly about his journey, one that began and ended with him saving lives and fixing people. There was no happier ending than seeing Jack finally gets to be the one whose problems get fixed himself, dying a the hero of all heroes in the reality and finally finding out that yes, his father really loved him, and so did everyone he spent those last years of his life with, in the purgatory of the flash-sideways universe, from those who always believed in him like Hurley and especially Kate, to those with whom he never saw eye-to-eye, like Locke.

And yes, I would have loved to have gotten a few more answers, or at least closure to some important characters, namely, Michael and Walt (who were shockingly and horrifically absent from the final church scene), but nothing is ever perfect, which was another underlying theme in the show. Just because something or someone is imperfect doesn't mean it or they are now undeserving of being loved.


With the finale in the books, I can say that I'm glad I invested the last four years of my life viewing the show (I watched the first two seasons on DVD after getting on board in Season 3). It was a very rewarding and enriching experience, a great fable with intelligence and science-fiction sensibilities that now I will not be able to find anywhere on TV now that Flash Forward is going off the air. Oh well, at least I'll still have Chuck, Venture Bros. and It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia.

Godspeed and farewell, LOST. You are a show that now belongs to the ages.

Remember you can contact TH and ask him questions about wrestling, life or anything else. Please refer to this post for contact information. He always takes questions!

7 comments:

  1. I am going to have to watch many an episode again before I ultimately decide whether this was a fitting finale or not.

    I am a Lost devotee. I've never missed an episode and am critically anal when it comes to plotlines and details. That being said, I was delighted with the basic conclusion to the "story". I accept the story in its simplest form as being the tale of failed individuals sought out for martyr's work, only realizing what their role is when they go back to what they failed at in the first place. The final season is the culmination of what they were brought to do, succeeding in life in ways they had only dreamed of. I can dig that. It's a truly memorable story and is filled with twists and turns and is told extremely well.

    I think I have a problem however, in accepting the alternate reality as anything other than filler to beef out the final season. That's the reason I'll need to watch it all again, to find justification for it -- I fear though, that I wont find it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I thought it was a very satisfying conclusion to the series. I think if people walk away from this upset about why they never explained the polar bears or exactly who the DHARMA initiative was and what they wanted, then they sort of missed the larger point. Not that there aren't a load of lingering unanswered questions, it's just that some of them matter more than others and for the story to reach a suitable conclusion, not all of them needed to be answered. I think around Season 3 there was a very noticeable change where it became clear that not everything was integral to the story being told and not everything would be 100% explained. I think that those of us who accepted that probably enjoyed the last few seasons a lot more because of it.

    Specifically, I found the "alternate reality as purgatory" storyline last night immensely satisfying and I think it hit all the right notes. The only real disappointment that I felt was in not seeing Michael or Walt, but in thinking on it further today, despite their importance to the story at the start, they weren't absolutely crucial and with Michael getting his send-off earlier this season, Walt's presence would have been weird and it was probably better that he was left out.

    The actual end of the adventures on the island was also well done. The revelation of Smokey needing the power of the island to be shut off so that he could escape, and Jack needing the power of the island to be turned off so he could kill Smokey was tremendous, and Desmond's part as the one who turns the switch - which is really what he has always been - was absolutely classic. The fact that Alpert also lost his immortality with the power outage was great too. I assume that Hurley and Ben each become protected now that the power is back on, but I don't even really need to know that answer to be honest. Oh - and I love the idea of Hurley and Ben bringing Desmond to the boat that Kate and Sawyer took to get to the plane and letting him sail away, even if they only hinted at it.

    Overall, this season, like the show as a whole, had it's ups and downs (still shaking my head at the Allison Janney episode), but it offered far more good than bad and again, while there are some questions that remain, I've got no major complaints with the way they wrapped things up.

    ReplyDelete
  3. i've watched the pilot and the finale and I'm glad I didn't waste anymore time on dead people doing things that in the end, didn't really matter.

    ReplyDelete
  4. My beef with the show is that Cuse and Lindelof said they weren't doing purgatory, and then after they said that, they introduce purgatory. It's easier to fool someone as a storyteller if you lie to their face.

    It was a satisfying finale for the characters, and cause they said this is a character driven show(which I kinda think is part cop out, part legit), it's a good finale. For the mythology of the show though? Whether that was the crux of it or not, I didn't feel as satisfied. I get the polar bears(or can draw my own conclusions, Dharma brought 'em there, the island was moved once before by the wheel and at that time it was stationed in the arctic, etc etc), but I felt there were too many questions brought up early in the series that were ignored outright in a "eh, it doesn't matter, look! Charlie and Claire! TOGETHER AGAIN!"

    And if they were in purgatory, and they couldn't die(See: Desmond running over Locke then wanting to do it again), how did Keamy and those others "die" at the hands of Sayid?

    I hoped, halfway through, and when Desmond removed the pillar and destroyed the light, that Desmond was collecting everyone to go back and fix their mistakes, not just walk into a shiny light.

    Maybe cause I don't believe in heaven and hell I couldn't swallow it as easily.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I just like the concept of alternate realities much more than I do the concept of heaven and hell.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think Cuse and Lindelof said that the island wasn't Purgatory, not that they wouldn't introduce Purgatory into the show at all. I would be all over the alternate reality as Purgatory thing as a cop out if they hadn't satisfied what they needed to with whoever was left on the island and giving a reasonable explanation for them getting off the island, but they did that. I feel like all of this season's flashes and the "moving on" stuff with Jack and Christian is more of an epilogue to the whole series than anything else.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I really enjoyed the end of lost but feel cheated by the writer's a bit.

    ReplyDelete